M, b. 23 December 1683, d. 2 April 1768
|Father||Jonathan Horton I Captain b. 23 Feb 1646, d. 23 Feb 1707|
|Mother||Bethia Wells b. 1655, d. between the 11th & 16th April|
Jonathan was born on Thursday, 23 December 1683 in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, Long Island, New York. Jonathan married Mary Tuthill on 27 November 1707 in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, Long Island, New York.3 Jonathan departed this life on Saturday, 2 April 1768 in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, Long Island, New York. He was buried at Suffolk County, Long Island, New York, in the Southold Town Cemetery.
|Mary Tuthill b. 1687, d. 4 Mar 1780|
- [S136] Adeline Horton White, Hortons In America, page 408-409 - Jonathan, s/o Jonathan Horton and Bethia Wells,
born at the "Old Castle", 23 Dec., 1683; married 27 Nov., 1707, Mary Tuthill, daughter of Henry Tuthill, brother of John Tuthill, the Puritan. He died 2 April, 1768; she died. Both buried in Southold
Cemetery. Children: Mary [1708 m. Edward Mabel], Eliphaz [1710 - disappeared when 18 & never heard from], Mehitable [1712 m. 12/02/1743 Walter Brown, his 3rd wife], Azariah W. [3/20/1715, was married], Lazarus/Lawrence [1717, m. Anna Corey], Ambrose .
- [S264] Whitaker, History of Southold, 1640-1740, page 265 - Azariah's mother was Mary Tuthill. Her family being one of the earliest in the town. John Tuthill being the chief executive officer there in 1642. His father was Jonathan, son of Jonathan of Barnabas. Azariah was born 20 March 1715.
- [S181] William Salmon, The Salmon Records, a Private Registar of Marriages & Deaths of the Residents of the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, N.Y., and of persons more or less closely associated with that place, 1696-1811., p. 119.